Understanding the Structural Stability of the Tehri Dam:A Comprehensive Analysis
Abstract
Abstract
The Tehri dam is the highest dam in India. The height of dam is 260 m. It is situated on the Himalayan
region which is in earthquake prone region. A Sengupta in 2006 found that the predicted deformation
due to an M=7.0 earthquake are not large enough to compromise the safety of the dam. However the
deformation predicted by Seed and Makdisi’s method, and Bureau’s method for an M=8.5 earthquake
are large enough to compromise the safety of dam. The Seed and Makdisi’s procedure predicted the
maximum deformations, while the minimum deformations are computed by Jansen’s method. In the
present work, the stability analysis four type of analysis such as structural stability analysis, Centre of
slip circle by genetic algorithm, stability of dam under sudden draw down condition and dynamic
analysis are considered. Structural stability analysis have done by Fellenius method and radial slice
method. In Fellenius method three number of slip circles are taken which cuts the slope at two third
distances from top of slope. By finding the resisting moment and driving moment the factor of safety is found that for first slip circle, second slip circle and third slip circle are 1.997,2.103 and 2.045
respectively. In the radial slice method the failure wages are divided into number of slice radially by
joining the line from the center of slip circle to the arch. The factor of safety is found as 1.15. The
coordinate of Centre of slip circle has been found by genetic algorithm. In order to validate the
genetic algorithm method, the input data has been imported from the results of graphical method. The centre coordinate of slip circle is obtained as (210,485) which was found to be very close to the value of Centre of slip circle by graphical method. Numerical analysis has been made by using
commercially available software PLAXIS under sudden draw down condition. The deformation in X
direction was 16.99 m. Dynamic analysis has been used by PLAXIS software and the total
deformation is obtained as 0.4150 m. T
Keyword: Slope stability Analysis, Dynamic Analysis, Factor of Safety, Tehri Dam
Refrences:
1. Giri. D, Nayak.T, “Analysis of Failed Teton Dam” ijert, ISSN: 2278-0181 Vol. 5 Issue 09,
September-2016
2. Kumar.G.P , Das.A,Rai. R,Jaiswal.A, “Slope Stability Analysis Using Radial Slices: A
Mathematical Model” J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. D (July–December 2015) 96(2):189–193
3. Lane, P.A. & Griffiths, D.V. 2000. Assessment of stability of slopes under drawdown conditions.
Jnl. Geotech. and Geoenv. Engng. 126(5): 443–450.
4. Lawrence Von Thun, J. 1985. San Luis Dam upstream slide, Int. Conf. on Soil Mech. Found. Eng.
11, 2593–2598.
5. Makdisi F I , Seed H B 1978 simplified procedure for estimating dam and embankment
earthquake induced deformations. J. Geotech. Eng. div. ASCE 104(7): 849–867
6. Morgenstern 1963. Stability charts for earth slopes during rapid drawdown. Géotechnique
13(1):121–131.
7. Paton, J., & Semple, N.G. 1961. Investigation of the stability of an earth dam subjected to rapid
drawdown including details of pore pressure recorded during a controlled drawdown test. Pore
pressure and suction in soils: 85-90. Butterworths, London.
8. Pauls, G.J., Karlsauer, E., Christiansen, E.A. &Wigder, R.A. 1999. A transient analysis of slope
stability following drawdown after flooding of highly plastic clay. Can. Geotech. Jnl. 36:
1151–1171
9. PLAXIS 2D Tutorial manual, 2015
10. Reinius, E. 1954. The stability of the slopes of earth dams. Géotechnique 5: 181–189.
11. Sandipa.SPandey.S (2013) A case study on Tehri dam
12. Seed H B, Lee K L ,Idriss I M 1969 analysis of the Sheffield dam failure. J. Soil Mech. Found.
Div. ASCE 95(6): 1453–1490
13. Sengupta.A,”Esimation of Permanent Deformation of Tehri Dam Due to 7.0 And 8.5 Magnitude
Earthquakes” Advances in Earth Structures: Research to Practice (GSP 151),ASCE 2006
14. Sengupta A, Martin P P 1997 Earthquake-induced permanent deformations in earth dams: From a
challenge to practice, ICOLD 97, Madrid, Spain
15. Sengupta .A ,Upadhyay.A, “Locating the critical failure surface in a slope stability analysis by
genetic algorithm” Applied Soft Computing 9 (2009) 387–392
16. Stephenson, D. 1978. Drawdown in embankments. Géotechnique 28(3): 273–280.
17. Swaisgood J R 1995 estimating deformation of embankment dams caused by earthquakes. ASDSO
Western Regional Conf. Montana, USA 1–7
18. W. Fellenius, Calculation of the stability of earth dams: Trans. 2nd Cong. on Large Dams, v.4.
(Washington D.C, 1936)
19. “Embankment Dam Engineering” by Bharat Singh and R.S. Varshney, Nem Chand & Bros
publication
20. Samal, R. and Mishra, A., 2020, November. Effect of Stone dust and Lime in the Geotechnical
Properties of Clayey Soil. In IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering (Vol.
970, No. 1, p. 012028). IOP Publishing.